The case relates to a deal in 2007 when vodafone, through its group firm vodafone international holdings, bought hutchison telecommunications indias htil stake in hutchison essar. The deal is vodafone s thirdbiggest ever and it beat three rival suitors for the stake, indias reliance communications and the hinduja and essar groups, the last of. In may 2007, vodafone took over hutchison essar india through a deal with hong. Apr 05, 2020 vodafone acquired htil hutchison telecom internationals 67% stake in hutchisonessar. Acquired bpl, vodafone and hutch merger mobile service provider in india retrieved 24 december this refers to the fact that the combined company can vldafone reduce its fixed costs by removing duplicate departments or operations. Amol sharma and lilly vitorovich explain why this might be good news for india. The vodafone hutchison case and its implications vccircle. The company vodafone essar limited has become one of the leading companies in the telecom sector in india due to its high standard of services that it provides to its customers. All you wanted to know about the vodafone tax case the. Our aim is to improve one billion lives and halve our environmental impact by 2025. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. The tax season just ended in india with the end of the year tax assessments on september 30 and many companies were busy with their filings. Vodafone s foray into india vodafone was looking to enter indian market.
One of the most controversial economic issues in the last five years was the tax dispute between vodafone and the tax department. Vodafone acquires the licences in remaining 7 circles and has starts its pending operations in madhya pradesh circle, as well as in orissa, assam, north east and bihar. Hutchison essar limited subsequently renamed vodafone essar ltd. Vodafone s creative math may pay off in hutchison essar deal updated feb. Vodafone is a leader in technology communications through mobile, fixed, broadband and tv. Finance secretary r s gujral had said in an interview with this newspaper on monday that even before the transaction between vodafone and hutchison was completed, the companies were advised that the deal was liable to tax.
Case on merger acquisition of hutch and vodafone marketing. Vodafone must pay withholding tax, govt told hutchison essar. Jun 26, 2017 vodafone company in england wanted to enter in indian market in 2007. Dec 22, 2006 london vodafone group, the worlds largest cellphone company, said friday that it might make an offer for a controlling interest in hutchison essar, the indian wireless operator. But fdi policies were not favorable on feb 11, 2007 a vodafone group plc an uk based telec. Last week, the government announced that it was giving up its conciliation talks with the global giant and was going ahead with its earlier tax demand relating to the hutchvodafone deal of. Revenue dept, courts asked to take holistic view the.
What exactly was the problem in the vodafonehutchison tax. Kong based hutchison, which sold its shares of hutch india via an indirect. Delhi i hutchison telecom east limited kolkata i hutchison essar cellular limited. In the yearthe worlds largest telecom company in terms of revenue, vodafone plc vodafone made a major foray into the indian telecom market by acquiring a 52 percent stake in the indian telecom company, hutchison essar ltd hutchison essarthrough a deal with the hong kongbased hutchison telecommunication international ltd.
Vodafones foray into india vodafone was looking to enter indian market. Vodafone hutchison deal news and updates from the economic. It was revenues view that the cayman islands company bought by vodafone to get control of hutchison essar. It dept says it has jurisdiction to tax vodafonehutch deal. In the year 2007, the worlds largest telecom company in terms of revenue, vodafone plc vodafone made a major foray into the indian telecom market by acquiring a 52 percent stake in the indian telecom company, hutchison essar ltd hutchison essar, through a deal with the hong kongbased hutchison telecommunication international ltd. Hutchison essar, spacetel deal done the economic times. Analysis of vodafone essar india mergers and acquisitions. Vodafone claims it is not an agent of hutchison, files. Vodafone acquires hutchison essar stake financial times. Relations between hutchison telecom and the essar group of india will be key to the sale of hutchs 67% stake in hutch essar.
A man walks past a hutch logo in mumbai in a file photo. Unnikrishnan the governments ongoing scrutiny of a multibillion dollar stake in hutchison essar ltd by vodafone group in the booming. Cayman island mauritius was a 100 % subsidiary of hutchison hongkong. Vodafone essar, previously hutchison essar is a cellular operator in india that covers 23 telecom circles in. Essar confirmed that it had received an offer to partner. British telecom giant vodafone has decided against making a provision in its balance sheet for the over rs 11,000 tax claim made by indian authorities for its 2007 deal to acquire stake in hutchison essar. Acquisition of hutchison essar india by vodafone u. Vodafone idea limited is an indian telecom operator with its headquarters based in mumbai, maharashtra and gandhinagar, gujarat. Vodafone s purchase of hutchison essar parties to the deal. Under the terms of the deal, the vodafone group holds a 45. The deal was reached after months of negotiations between the two groups and after vodafone. Comerford acquisition of hutchison essar india by vodafone u. The partners have agreed that hutchison essar will be renamed vodafone essar and, in due course, that the business will market its products and services under the vodafone brand.
Mergers and acquistions mergers and acquisitions parvesh. Mutual distrust y right time to quit indian operations to. Hutchison chairman also wrote to its shareholders in its annual report for the year 2006 as under. Vodafone idea is a panindia integrated gsm operator offering 2g, 3g and 4g volte mobile services under two brands named vodafone and idea. Vodafone opens hutchison essars books financial times. As of march 2018, vodafone india has a market share of 21% and with its merger with idea, the collective vodafone idea network has approximately 375 million subscribers and is the second largest mobile. Vodafone india is the indian subsidiary of ukbased vodafone group plc and is a provider of.
Essar files objection with fipb to hutch vodafone deal, asserts that it has a right of first refusal. International journal of advance research in computer. In 2007, worlds one of the largest telecommunication country from revenue point of view vodafone played a major role and decided to expand their business in indian by acquiring 52% of shares of hutchison. I am particularly pleased to report on the proposed sale of the groups interests in india, attracted some of the worlds leading mobile operators to approach and ultimately make an offer for the groups entire interests in its. It claimed that capital gains tax most people paid on the transaction and that tax should have been deducted by vodafone while paying. Vodafone essar started its operations in india in 1994 and is under the vodafone group. It discusses the rationale for vodafones acquisition of 67% stake in hutch essar. Vodafone wins rs 11,000 crore tax case the times of india. Last week, the government announced that it was giving up its conciliation talks with the global giant and was going ahead with its earlier tax demand relating to the hutch vodafone deal of. We also offer free sim home delivery with new postpaid connection.
Vodafones creative math may pay off in hutchison essar deal updated feb. Acquisition of hutch by vodafone pdf vodafone acquired htil hutchison telecom internationals 67% stake in hutchisonessar. Vodafone acquires the licences in remaining 7 circles and has starts its pending operations in madhya pradesh circle, as. Vodafone hutchison deal vodafone acquired htil hutchison telecom internationals 67% stake in hutchison essar. Merger of vodafone and hutch companies business scribd. Vodafone hutch deal news and updates from the economic. Regulatory approvals vodafone acquisition is subject to a number of approvals including from the department of telecommunications and the government fipb. Since the deal was offshore, neither party thought it was taxable in. Vodafone managed to navigate the auction process quickly and get a price thats close to what we were thinking in december, when rumors of a deal began to stir. Vodafone acquired htil hutchison telecom internationals 67% stake in hutchison essar. The takeover of hutchison essar will expand vodafone s worldwide subscribers by 8. Vodafone says it may acquire stake in hutchison essar. Vodafone gets daytoday control of hutchison essar reuters. Firstly, by making its own infrastructure, opening braches across india, recruiting its workers and what not.
Vodafone and essar have reached an agreement under which they will work to continue the growth of hutchison essar limited. Vodafone wins control of hutchison essar of india business. Merger a merger involves the mutual decision of two companies to combine and become one 1992. Vodafone india is the indian subsidiary of ukbased vodafone group plc and is a provider of telecommunications services in india with its operational head office in mumbai. Telkom, africas largest fixedline company, was close to a deal to sell its interest in vodacom to vodafone, which has preemptive rights to the shares. Mar 08, 2019 in the yearthe worlds largest telecom company in terms of revenue, vodafone plc vodafone made a major foray into the indian telecom market by acquiring a 52 percent stake in the indian telecom company, hutchison essar ltd hutchison essarthrough a deal with the hong kongbased hutchison telecommunication international ltd. Vodafone company in england wanted to enter in indian market in 2007. Hmtl was renamed hutchison essar limited hel in august 2005.
Essar there are two main reasons which are responsible for li kashing to leave india. Vodafone idea has a broadband network of 340,000 sites, distribution reach of 1. Last year british telecom giant vodafone paid hong kong based hutchison international over usd 11 billion to buy hutchison s 67% stake in indian telecom company hutchison essar. The takeover of hutchison essar will expand vodafones worldwide subscribers by 8. Acquisition of hutchison essar india by vodafone aaa digital. Vodafone india wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. Were working hard to build a digital future that works for everyone. The case originated after the revenues tax department notice to vodafone that the company has to pay a capital gains tax of nearly rs 1 crores from its purchase of hutchison essar telecom company from hutch.
Mar 15, 2007 vodafone gets daytoday control of hutchison essar. However, the merged entity continues using both the idea and vodafone brand. Vodafones creative math may pay off in hutchison essar deal. Hutchison essar, spacetel deal done hutchison essar has completed the acquisition of essar spacetel from the essar group, reports our bureau. Vodafone casesummarised by rohit kapoor vodafone case summarised by rohit kapoor facts of the case. On 31 august 2018, vodafone india merged with idea cellular, and was renamed as vodafone idea limited.
The company refused to pay the capital gains tax arguing that the transaction. But fdi policies were not favorable on feb 11, 2007 a vodafone group plc an uk based telecom company acquired hutchison essar ltd hel. The hutchison essar group contained 67 % stake of hutch and 33% stake of essar. Vodafone hutchison deal is a share sale, not asset sale.
Merger of vodafone and hutch free download as pdf file. It could effect fdi inflows due to perception of unpredicitable tax implications. Vodafone argued that the deal was not taxable in india as the funds were. Hutchison hongkong is a non resident having no tax implications in india. Hutch essar structure said cleared in india reuters. In april 2014, india based piramal group sold its 11% stake in vodafone india to prime metals, an indirect subsidiary of vodafone group. Case on merger acquisition of hutch and vodafone marketing essay. Vodafone makes no provision for hutch deal tax claim. Indias law ministry has cleared the shareholding structure in mobile phone operator hutchison essar ahead of. Read more about vodafone must pay withholding tax, govt told hutchison essar on business standard. Vodafone hutchison deal news and updates from the economictimes. Banerjee vodafone and hutch merger, aims to deliver a complete vodafone knowledge to customers.
1251 182 225 422 748 1137 1521 1349 599 457 401 758 691 1363 1254 1340 1352 307 554 277 973 24 592 907 1023 1399 680 1198 190 115 861 609 331 1298 370 956 1003 382 934